Which coin should I choose??

[Brad]

PCGS is giving members the chance for one free secure plus regrade. I would like to send one of my more expensive coins. Which should I choose?

1909 S VDB AU55 I think this coin is accurately graded, and probably would not get a plus.

1955 DDO 1 MS62BN I think this coin could get a plus, but probably not get a 63.

1922 No D VF35 Slight chance to get upgraded to an XF, coins under XF45 cannot get a plus.

1972 DDO 1 MS66RD Little chance of 67 or a plus in my opinion.

1914 D XF45 Little change of upgrade or plus.

1928 Peace Dollar MS62 Chance of upgrade and chance of plus.
My favorite non-lincoln coin

1916 D Dime VG10 Slight chance of upgrade, cannot plus.

[jhracing08]

I would send in the 1955 DDO, 1972 DDO, or 1928 Peace Dollar. I'm curious to see which one you chose. I wish you luck Brad.

[copper_poisoning]

1955 or the 1928 Peace dollar.

Greg

[jhracing08]

Wait a minute.....

I thought Mint Errors and Special Issues are excluded from the offer?

So you couldn't send in the Doubled Dies right?

[RWBILLER]

Brad:
Im sending in my 1914-D, my 09-s vdb and 55 ddo are ngc and you cant crossover.
I will let everybody know how i am doing. Send your 55 ddo.
thx
roger

[RpmHunter]

Brad,

I would send the coin that you think may get the + upgrade. You have satisfaction owning a high end for the grade example (which you already knew before the re-submit) and the value will be increased if/when you decide to sell it.

Scott

[hasfam]

I agree with sending in the 55 DDO. Good luck Brad.
Rock

[jcuve]

The '55 or the '28...

[trails]

I would go with the 1928-P Peace dollar. My wife has one in her collection graded at MS-63.

BJ Neff

[ericodapro]

I would do the '28 if you thought it would be upgraded.. or the s vdb for the fact that it would really boost the value if bumped to ms60

[Brad]

Here are some pics of the 1928 Peace Dollar

[koinmon]

Brad I think I'll go against the grain and select the 16-D so much more upward price potential ( IN MY OPINION ).
George

[Brad]

I decided to send the 1955 doubled die. After analizing the 1916 D I decided that it was to worn to be a Fine. After looking at the 1955 doubled die again in person (I had to get it out of the safety deposit box), I think the 1955 has a chance of MS63. We will see what PCGS thinks.

[jpl6332]

Well Brad whatever your choice I want you to know I am pulling for you and lets hope the graders get a pay raise the day your coin is on the line.

[Brad]

Thanks! It is supposed to take 5 days....